The findings of this study revealed statistically significant associations between certain individual factors (sex and age), occupational factors (job level), and biomechanical factors and the presence of musculoskeletal symptoms. These results are consistent with previous studies highlighting the multifactorial nature of musculoskeletal disorders37-42 and are consistent with the biopsychosocial approach, in which biomechanical exposures and individual and occupational characteristics may contribute to the occurrence of symptoms in different body segments.
In this regard, the ERIN method enables the assessment of critical postures adopted by workers while performing various tasks, including the positioning of the neck, back, arms, and wrists20,23,30,43. Although it shares similarities with methods such as RULA4, REBA5, and OWAS9, ERIN incorporates additional variables that complement the postural assessment, including perceived exertion and work pace. These variables are not routinely included in other observational assessment methods and may provide additional information about the demands associated with task performance. Therefore, ERIN may serve as a useful tool for identifying ergonomic risks and supporting decision-making related to occupational health promotion and disease prevention within organizations.
Studies conducted by Ruíz30 and Rodríguez et al.22 have reported the feasibility of applying the ERIN method in workplace settings, highlighting its ease of assessment, item scoring, and interpretation of results. Similarly, research has been conducted across diverse work environments, including the food industry21, mining31, and glass manufacturing44; however, the present study extends the application of the instrument to the context of healthcare professionals.
The results showed a statistically significant association between female sex and the presence of neck symptoms (OR = 2.13; 95% CI = 1.162-3.907; p = 0.013), which was consistent with the observed correlations between female sex and symptoms reported at 7 days (r = 0.150) and 12 months (r = 0.140). These findings are consistent with reports from countries such as China, where musculoskeletal complaints have been reported more frequently among women45, as well as findings among surgeons46 and studies of nonspecific neck pain among physicians and nurses, in which female sex was associated with a higher prevalence of neck symptoms47. However, among nurses, neck pain was found to be more closely associated with weekly hours of exposure and work experience48. Other studies suggest that these findings may be related to exposure duration, non-work-related physical loads, and biomechanical differences associated with workstation design and anthropometric characteristics, particularly when female workers are required to maintain prolonged neck-flexion postures2,49.
Other tools applied in healthcare settings—such as the Quick Exposure Check (QEC)50, Strain Index51-55, and OCRA52,48,55, as well as applications such as the WERA Tool56—have also identified significant associations between neck postures and self-reported symptoms in the neck region. The relationship between gender and reported symptoms described above may stem from biomechanical and hormonal differences, as well as non-work-related demands, including domestic and caregiving responsibilities. However, the literature emphasizes that observational methods may underestimate the risk associated with biomechanical load exposure57. Assessing neck flexion and corrective factors, such as neck-head rotation and lateral flexion, may improve the precision of identifying cervical postures that increase workers' risk of musculoskeletal symptoms51.
Consistent with the international literature, this study found a statistically significant association between female sex and the presence of upper-body symptoms, specifically in the right shoulder (OR = 2.480; 95% CI = 1.061-5.795), as well as correlations with symptoms reported during the previous 7 days (r = 0.130; p ≤ 0.05) and previous 12 months (r = 0.163; p ≤ 0.01). Similar associations were observed for the left shoulder, with symptoms reported during the previous 7 days (r = 0.150; p ≤ 0.05) and previous 12 months (r = 0.145; p ≤ 0.05)58-61. These results are similar to those reported by Abo-Naser et al.46, who found that female surgeons had a 7.81-fold higher risk of experiencing symptoms. Similarly, in Ghana, women were found to have a 1.66-fold higher risk62. A similar pattern was observed among Chinese workers, among whom the prevalence of shoulder problems was 49%63; a systematic review reported an average prevalence of self-reported shoulder symptoms of 40.9%64. These findings are consistent with those reported by Lin et al.64, who suggested that bilateral shoulder involvement may reflect greater exposure to overuse and the adoption of non-neutral postures.
Along these lines, the present study identified statistically significant differences regarding the female gender and symptoms in the right hand/wrist ([OR = 2.980; 95% CI = 1.342-6.619] symptoms in the last 7 days [r = 0.168; p ≤ 0.01]; symptoms in the last 12 months [r = 0.130; p ≤ 0.01]) and the left hand/wrist ([OR = 3.469; 95% CI = 1.188-10.128] symptoms in the last 7 days [r = 0.145; p ≤ 0.05]; symptoms in the last 12 months [r = 0.127; p ≤ 0.05]); these findings are similar to those described for surgical tasks (OR = 5.31; 95% CI = 1.14-27.1)46. Likewise, a meta-analysis by Koyuncu et al.48 reports a 29% prevalence of wrist pain, characterized by higher frequency in settings requiring highly repetitive movements and non-neutral wrist postures—specifically flexion, extension, and radial and ulnar deviation—typical of surgical tasks and specialized nursing and dental procedures22,65. In this regard, one of the strengths of the ERIN method compared to other assessment methods is that, in addition to biomechanical load, it allows for the consideration of elements such as effort and movement frequency.
Being female was also associated with upper back symptoms, showing a 3.251 times higher likelihood (95% CI: 1.671-12.882) compared to men; this was corroborated by Pearson correlation analysis between gender and upper back symptoms at seven days (r = 0.218; p ≤ 0.01) and at one year (r = 0.200; p ≤ 0.01). A link between being female and upper back symptoms was also found among Turkish nurses (OR = 1.42866—similar to findings in an African study (OR = 1.66)62—although among surgical professionals, the highest rates of reported symptoms involved the shoulders46,48. Thus, it is imperative not only to analyze individual variables but also to establish the relationship between physical workload and reported symptoms among healthcare personnel.
This study identified that workers scoring in the medium- and high-risk categories for trunk posture were 2.185 times more likely to report symptoms in the buttocks and/or hips (95% CI: 1.027-4.651). This finding is consistent with research by Nascimento et al.67, who demonstrated that adopting non-neutral postures involving the lower limbs and trunk was associated with a greater likelihood of reporting hip and thigh symptoms (β = 0.219). Similarly, prolonged static postures have been associated with hip symptoms among orthopedic surgeons68. However, meta-analyses have identified the hip as one of the body segments with the lowest prevalence of musculoskeletal symptoms (21.9%)64, suggesting that symptoms in this region may be related to the cumulative effects of trunk fatigue and biomechanical load.
In contrast to previously reported findings, a distinctive finding of the present study was the association between pace and speed and the presence of elbow symptoms (OR = 4.412; 95% CI: 1.555-12.518). Globally, the prevalence of elbow symptoms has been reported to range from 14.6% to 17.3%64,69. These results may be explained by sustained muscle tension during tasks requiring shoulder elevation and abduction66, combined with gripping activities involving forceful exertion and repetitive movements, which may increase mechanical loading and contribute to symptom persistence in the elbow region.
Regarding workers who scored at medium- or high-risk levels for physical exertion and frequency of technical actions, those exposed to these levels had 1.960-fold higher odds of reporting lower back symptoms; notably, a substantial proportion of the workers assessed were part of the clinical care staff. In this regard, Koyuncu et al.48 highlighted that biomechanical load and task repetitiveness are among the main determinants of low back pain. Similarly, a study conducted in China identified heavy workloads as a predictor of lumbar musculoskeletal disorders63. It has also been reported that nursing staff involved in patient-transfer activities face a higher risk of intervertebral disc injuries7, a risk that has likewise been documented among emergency healthcare personnel48.
In line with these findings, a significant correlation was identified between the level of biomechanical risk and symptoms reported in the left shoulder during the previous 12 months (r = 0.149; p ≤ 0.05), consistent with findings reported in the existing literature. Using the RULA assessment, Gao et al.70 found that non-neutral arm postures were associated with the presence of upper-body pain. Similarly, Davison et al., using the REBA tool to assess emergency and nursing personnel, reported a positive relationship between higher arm scores and shoulder symptoms71. Consistent with these findings, significant correlations were also identified between medium- and high-level biomechanical risk and bilateral elbow symptoms (r = 0.149 and r = 0.158, respectively; p ≤ 0.05). These findings suggest that biomechanical demands associated with technical tasks and repetitive arm movements may be related to the occurrence of elbow symptoms. However, this association warrants further investigation in future studies involving populations with similar occupational characteristics.
Furthermore, the results obtained in this study using the ERIN tool demonstrated an association between biomechanical risk level and symptoms in the lumbar region, consistent with findings reported in other economic sectors, such as the food industry1 and underground mining31. However, no studies were identified that specifically applied the ERIN method among healthcare workers. Other studies have used various assessment methods and reported significant associations between postural load resulting from manual handling of loads and musculoskeletal symptoms72-77, as well as between symptoms and awkward or sustained postures39,78-85. Studies reporting symptoms in the upper back and lumbar region have shown a higher prevalence among female healthcare workers in clinical care settings, who report greater exposure to sustained postures and trunk flexion, largely due to tasks inherent to patient care(.
Moreover, it is important to highlight that the implementation of corrective and preventive measures may improve workstation design and reduce musculoskeletal symptoms, as demonstrated by Rodríguez et al.1 in a study of workers in a meat-processing plant. In this regard, the findings concerning elevated biomechanical risk associated with awkward postures involving the arm, elbow, and lumbar region in the assessed sample underscore the importance of adjusting work surfaces to facilitate more functional and neutral upper-body postures. Additionally, the use of mechanical aids during patient mobilization may help reduce the risk of injury to the lumbar and shoulder regions50,67.
Finally, identifying critical subtasks and redesigning tasks and exposure times are essential components of ergonomic intervention. In this context, Amirmahani et al.88 recommend hierarchical task analysis, which involves identifying critical subtasks and subsequently determining the points during which biomechanical risk is greatest, thereby facilitating the development of targeted recommendations and task redesign strategies.
Furthermore, task alternation and reduced exposure times may facilitate periods of joint rest and musculoskeletal recovery, practices that are also supported by the literature. For example, in hospital settings with high biomechanical demands, such as operating rooms, intensive care units, and dental clinics, periodic job rotation and active breaks have been recommended89,90. Wang et al.63 emphasized that stretching exercises may act as a protective factor against musculoskeletal injuries. Finally, several studies underscore the importance of assessing biomechanical risk using standardized tools capable of identifying postures adopted during different tasks while accounting for anatomical planes and corrective factors, thereby reducing the likelihood of underestimating ergonomic risk43,91.
# Limitations
The study had several limitations. First, access to staff and their willingness to complete the musculoskeletal symptom questionnaire were limited, which may have affected participation. Second, in some departments, confidentiality and patient privacy requirements prevented the collection of photographs for postural load assessment, limiting the observation of certain work activities. Third, the available literature on the application of the ERIN method among healthcare professionals was scarce, which limited direct comparison of the findings with studies conducted in comparable healthcare populations.